A two-storey red-brick house with a lit front porch at dusk, set behind a mown lawn and a mature shade tree.

Home Insurance

Sutherland Insurance is a fifth-generation independent brokerage in Guelph, Ontario that has brokered home insurance since 1870. Home insurance is not required by Ontario law, and mortgage lenders require it as a condition of financing. Sutherland Insurance compares more than 10 personal-lines carriers on every quote request.

Key takeaways

  • Home insurance is not required by Ontario law, and Ontario mortgage lenders require proof of coverage as a condition of advancing funds.
  • An Ontario homeowner policy combines four parts: the dwelling, detached private structures, contents, and personal liability.
  • The dwelling limit on an Ontario home policy is the cost to rebuild the house, which moves independently of the property's market value.
  • Overland water and sewer backup are optional endorsements on Ontario home policies and are not included in a standard policy by default.
Who it is for
Ontario residents who own and occupy their home
Legally required in Ontario
No, not required by provincial law
Commonly required by
Mortgage lenders, as a condition of financing
Standard parts of the policy
Dwelling, detached private structures, contents, and personal liability
Basis of the dwelling limit
Reconstruction cost, not market value or purchase price
Personal-lines markets compared
10+ Canadian carriers

What is home insurance?

Home insurance is a package policy covering the structure of a private home, the detached structures on its property, the belongings inside it, and the owner's legal liability to other people. An Ontario homeowner policy also pays additional living expenses while the home is uninhabitable after an insured loss. It is issued to the homeowner and is separate from any coverage a mortgage lender carries on its own interest.

Ontario homeowner policies are written on either a Named Perils Form or a Comprehensive Form. A Named Perils Form responds only to the causes of loss the wording lists; a Comprehensive Form responds to any cause of loss it does not exclude. Which form an insurer offers depends on the dwelling's age, its construction, and the condition of its roof, wiring, plumbing and heating.

What can an Ontario home insurance policy cover?

What a policy can cover

  • The dwelling itself, its attached structures and its built-in systems, against insured perils including fire, wind, hail and sudden water escape
  • Detached private structures on the property such as a garage, shed, fence or deck
  • Contents including furniture, appliances, clothing, electronics and tools owned by the household
  • Personal liability when a member of the household is found legally responsible for injury to another person or damage to their property
  • Additional living expenses for accommodation, meals and storage while the home is uninhabitable after an insured loss
  • Optional endorsements including sewer backup, overland water, equipment breakdown, service line coverage and scheduled high-value items

Commonly excluded under standard Ontario home insurance wordings

  • Overland water and sewer backup, unless the corresponding endorsement is added to the policy
  • Damage from wear and tear, gradual deterioration, settling, or a lack of maintenance
  • Damage caused by rodents, insects, vermin, or by mould arising over time
  • Loss to a dwelling left vacant beyond the period stated in the policy wording
  • Earthquake damage, unless the earthquake endorsement is added to the policy
  • Property used primarily for a business run from the home, above the standard sub-limit

Exclusions vary by insurer and by policy form; the issued policy governs.

How much does home insurance cost in Ontario?

The factors that move an Ontario home insurance premium, in approximate order of influence, and why insurers look at each one.

The factors that move an Ontario home insurance premium, in approximate order of influence, and why insurers look at each one.
Rating factorWhy
Reconstruction cost of the dwellingThe dwelling limit sets the insurer's maximum exposure on a total loss.
Age of the roof, wiring, plumbing and heatingOlder systems carry higher fire, water and electrical claim frequencies.
Deductible selectedA higher deductible transfers more of each loss to the policyholder.
Postal code and rating territoryTerritories carry different fire, theft, water and severe-weather histories.
Distance to a fire hall and a hydrantResponse time changes the size of a fire loss.
Claims history on the propertyPrior claims are a rating factor for most Ontario insurers.
Optional endorsements addedSewer backup, overland water and scheduled items each add coverage and cost.
Bundling with an auto policyMost Ontario insurers file a multi-line discount.

Request a quote.

Do I need home insurance in Ontario?

Home insurance is not required by Ontario law. Mortgage lenders require proof of property insurance as a condition of advancing funds, which makes it a contractual requirement rather than a statutory one. For most owners the home is their single largest asset, and the cost of rebuilding it after a total loss falls entirely on the owner where no policy is in force. Some subdivision agreements and rural land leases impose the same term. Where a lender requires coverage, proof is provided before closing.

Which policy is arranged, and with which limits and endorsements, depends on circumstances that vary from one household to the next:

  • Whether a mortgage is registered on the property, and what the lender's insurance clause specifies.
  • The cost to rebuild the dwelling at current Ontario construction prices, which is not the purchase price.
  • The age and condition of the roof, electrical service, plumbing and heating systems.
  • Whether the property sits near a watercourse or on a sewer system with a history of backup.
  • Whether part of the home is rented out, used for a business, or left unoccupied for long periods.
  • Whether jewellery, art, bicycles or collections exceed the standard contents sub-limits.

What situations does Ontario home insurance commonly address?

Home policies are arranged for a wide range of ownership circumstances across Ontario, and the coverage available differs in each. The situations below are common among Sutherland Insurance clients in Guelph and across the province, and each one changes which options an insurer will offer on the policy.

  • A Guelph family buying a first home and arranging coverage to be in force on the closing date.
  • An owner of a century home in a Guelph heritage neighbourhood with knob-and-tube wiring or a 60-amp panel.
  • A homeowner whose finished basement sits below the municipal sewer line, where water endorsements are relevant.
  • A household renting out a basement unit, which moves part of the exposure outside a standard homeowner form.
  • A retired couple wintering away, where the unoccupancy conditions in the wording apply.
  • A homeowner with a detached workshop, an in-ground pool or a solar array on the property.

How do I get home insurance from Sutherland Insurance?

A quote is requested online or by calling 519-822-0160. A licensed Sutherland Insurance broker confirms the address, the age and construction of the dwelling, the condition of its systems, and the endorsements under consideration, and compares the available Ontario markets. Coverage is bound once the client confirms.

  1. Request a quote online, or call Sutherland Insurance at 519-822-0160.
  2. A licensed broker confirms the address, year built, square footage, construction, and the age of the roof, wiring, plumbing and heating.
  3. Sutherland Insurance compares the more than 10 personal-lines carriers it holds contracts with.
  4. The broker presents the available options and endorsements, and the client selects limits and deductibles.
  5. The broker binds coverage and confirms it to the mortgage lender where one is on title.

Why is my rebuild cost higher than my home's market value?

The dwelling limit on an Ontario home policy is the cost to rebuild the house on its existing lot at current labour and material prices. Market value is what a buyer would pay for the whole property, land included. The two figures move independently, and across much of Ontario the rebuild figure is the higher of the two.

A rebuild carries costs a sale price never does: clearing the site, removing debris, and bringing the new structure up to the current Ontario Building Code. Insurers recalculate reconstruction cost at every renewal from regional construction-cost data, which is why a dwelling limit rises in a year when nothing about the house changed.

Does home insurance cover flooding in Ontario?

A standard Ontario home policy excludes overland water. Overland water coverage (for water entering the home from an overflowing lake or river, or from heavy rainfall running across the ground) is sold as an optional endorsement. Sewer backup is a separate optional endorsement. Sudden and accidental escape from indoor plumbing is covered on most standard forms.

Sewer backup and overland water are distinct perils with distinct wordings, and a single storm can produce both at one address. Availability of the overland water endorsement depends on the property's flood-risk zone, and some insurers decline it on properties inside a regulated floodplain.

What makes Sutherland Insurance different from a direct insurer?

When a claim happens, Sutherland Insurance acts for the client with the insurer, and an in-house claims representative is available on any claim. Sutherland Insurance is an independent brokerage and compares 10+ Canadian insurers rather than selling one company’s product. A person answers the phone at Sutherland Insurance, 519-822-0160, Monday to Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

How Sutherland Insurance handles your insurance claim

Two people seated side by side at a wooden table, hands resting on an open notebook between two mugs of coffee.
Claims advocacy: Sutherland Insurance sits on the client's side of the table, not the insurer's.

Frequently asked questions

Is home insurance mandatory in Ontario?

Home insurance is not required by Ontario law. Mortgage lenders require proof of property insurance before advancing funds, which makes it a contractual requirement rather than a statutory one. That requirement holds for as long as the mortgage is registered on title. Sutherland Insurance issues proof of insurance to the lender directly.

What is the difference between a dwelling limit and market value?

A dwelling limit is the cost to rebuild a house on its existing lot at current Ontario labour and material prices. Market value is what a buyer would pay for the property, land included. The dwelling limit excludes the land and includes demolition, debris removal and building-code upgrades, so the two figures move independently.

Why did my home insurance premium go up when I made no claim?

Ontario home insurance premiums move with reconstruction costs, which insurers recalculate at each renewal from regional construction-cost data. Severe-weather losses across a rating territory, changes to an insurer's filed rates, and the age of a roof or heating system move the figure as well. A renewal increase is not evidence of a claim.

Can I insure a century home with knob-and-tube wiring in Guelph?

Some Ontario insurers write homes with knob-and-tube wiring and others decline them. Where coverage is available, an insurer commonly asks for an Electrical Safety Authority inspection report or a dated plan to replace the wiring. Sutherland Insurance places century-home coverage across more than 10 personal-lines carriers whose appetites for older wiring differ.

Does home insurance cover a business run from the home in Ontario?

A standard Ontario homeowner policy carries a small sub-limit for business property and excludes most business liability. Insurers offer a home-based business endorsement for smaller operations, and larger operations are written on a separate commercial policy. Which route applies depends on the type of business and the insurer's wording.

What happens to home insurance when a house is left vacant?

Ontario home policies carry vacancy and unoccupancy conditions that restrict certain coverage after a stated number of consecutive days, commonly thirty. Vacancy permits are available from some insurers where a property is between owners, under renovation, or empty for a season. Notifying the broker before that period begins keeps the condition from being triggered.

How many insurers does Sutherland Insurance compare for home insurance?

Sutherland Insurance compares more than 10 personal-lines carriers for Ontario home insurance. It is an independent brokerage licensed by the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario and is not tied to any single insurer. A licensed broker reviews the available markets.

These are the options. The right mix depends on the situation

The coverages above are the options generally available on an Ontario home insurance policy. Which of them belongs on any particular policy depends on the property, the people insured, the limits selected and the individual insurer's wording. The policy document itself always governs. A licensed Sutherland Insurance broker can walk through the options and build a plan around your circumstances. Call 519-822-0160 or request a quote.

Get your home insurance quote

A licensed Sutherland Insurance broker compares the available markets on every quote request.

Get your home insurance quote Call 519-822-0160

A real person answers, Monday to Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.